| pq |
|
| |
Reply with quote | #1 | I almost opted for the "ignore" option, but decided that certain things need to be said. I fear the fallout, but at least I had my say. My response to his email is below. Some of it will be familiar from my earlier post on the topic. ================================
I know that Mom is not an invalid. She could not do what she does if she were. No one respects her or what she does more than I do. But on a good day she works 18 hours as a full-time caregiver to Dad, which is a huge job in itself, all the while trying to keep up with the house and yard and dog and everything else. When Dad has one of his frequent bad bowel issues, she's pretty much working around the clock. She never has a day off. This would be an enormous challenge to a younger and healthier person. Mom is 81 years old, with diabetes, depression, high blood pressure, and high cholesterol, which put her at a high risk of stroke or heart attack. Her vision is very poor, and she is at great risk for falls. There's no way for her to EVER get caught up, to get the house clean and sanitary, and she hates that. Yet she won't allow outside help to come in because she thinks it is her duty to take care of everything herself as long as she is physically able to drag herself around. The ONLY respite she gets is if one of us visits and helps. Does she protest? YES. But if you just go ahead and refuse to argue about it, she's ultimately relieved and grateful. A year or more ago, she and I had our last discussion about this subject, and I basically said that, if she wasn't going to let aides or cleaners come in to help, that she should just expect me to do things around the house when I come, and I wasn't going to argue about it. So I do, and she gets a little respite. She'll stillsometimes protest a little , but the job is usually done by the time she's done, and then we get to spend time together, which is what she most wants when any of us are there. When I talked to Mom the other night, she was very enthusiastic about our bringing the sauce (which is already made and frozen from the last time we made a batch), as I've told her about it many times and she's said she'd like to try it ("I love meatballs!"). She will still be making all the Christmas dinner and I'm sure all kinds of cakes and cookies. Knowing her, she will also make a ham or something as well, but if she's tired or Dad's sick or any other of a number of unexpected events occur, she won't have to. She has always critical of her own cooking, but she has got less confident about it recently. Her stovetop barely works, her oven is iffy, and she doesn't see so well, and that all affects her abilities in the kitchen. We always tell her we love her cooking (and we do). Does she sometime squirm when we're cooking in her house? Yes, because she finds it hard to sit by and watch other people work. But she's getting used to it and enjoys it, and is GETTING A MOMENT OF REST, which she desperately needs. The house is dirty and in some cases unsanitary. Mom can't see well enough to clean very well any more. When she cooks, she often spills raw eggs and raw meat juices on other utensils or on clean dishes in the drying rack. That's unhealthy. That is why I clean up the kitchen as best I can and the bathroom that time. At least for a short time, I know they have a sanitary cooking area or a sanitary bathroom. She did ask me, and I agreed, that I won't clean the bathroom during the holidays, but I will clean the kitchen when we work in there for health reasons. I am asking you to be supportive of me here. It doesn't help when you reinforce to her the idea that no one else should lift a finger in her house but her. You have a huge influence over Mom's feelings: If you were supportive, she would be much more comfortable with accepting help. But when you act uncomfortable with it, she becomes uncomfortable and feels she must do everything herself. Helping is not taking over. And no matter how much I or you or BIL or SIL do, Mom will STILL run herself ragged with Christmas dinner, decorating, and presents. But this is a family holiday, and it's entirely appropriate for anyone in the family to contribute. That's what families do.
|
| Loading... | | |
| 2nd kathy |
|
| |
Reply with quote | #2 |
Amen...nicely written. You make all the right points and if he doesn't hear it, it remains that he wants control. I hope for you he just gets with the program. |
| Loading... | | |
| Olivia |
|
| |
Reply with quote | #3 | pq--
Way to go! (thumbs up) Glad you 'said what needed sayin'. Please keep us posted. I expect he'll huff, but so what. He needed to hear this.
best to you, o.
|
| Loading... | | |
| Farm Gal |
|
| |
Reply with quote | #4 |
Well stated, pq! Informative, and non-confrontational, while getting the point across. I LOVE that last paragraph. Hope brother gets the point! |
| Loading... | | |
| goodwillgal |
|
| |
Reply with quote | #5 | pq ditto to Farm Gal's post. VERY well put. blessings for positive results
|
| Loading... | | |
| lynn#1 |
|
| |
Reply with quote | #6 |
great reply....well written! I'm afraid hearing how your brother is...he won't accept it. But, you know, if he doesn't at least you have communicated your feelings, and taken the high road! |
| Loading... | | |
| pq |
|
| |
Reply with quote | #7 |
Thank you all for your encouragement. He's read it (I got the return receipt) but hasn't responded. I'm sure he is fuming. My cousin said "Who cares what he thinks?" That's the thing: I DON'T care what he thinks; I care about what he may do: call his mommy, upset her because PQ is being mean, or make a big stink at Christmas. I literally feel sick and dizzy when his replies come in, even the read receipts. |
| Loading... | | |
| Mary E. |
|
| |
Reply with quote | #8 | pq,
I admire you so much for telling the FACTS and stating your position calmly and with confidence.. Your brother may well be fuming, but it may be because his sister is standing up to him - he seems to be a "top dog" kind of guy.. So, expect some anger - but realize it's because his position and his ego are challenged.. You are in the right - and don't let him manipulate you into feeling otherwise.. If he's stuck up at Christmas, the best thing you could do is ignore it and act as if nothing has happened.. This would REALLY get his goat..
|
| Loading... | | |
| Jane in MA |
|
| |
Reply with quote | #9 | Great letter, pq. Maybe your brother needs a dose of salmonella or ecoli before he understands that you are doing this cleaning for everyone's benefit!
I remember visiting my grandmother when she and her BF were living independently in a ranch house in FLA. After pouring myself a glass of OJ from the pitcher she kept in the fridge, I noticed black rings around the inner bottom. Mold! Bacteria! I immediately washed it out well and never mentioned it so I would not embarrass her, but I also found a carton of sour milk, and a few other things that could make one sick. I was afraid to eat there.
My grandmother had always been the cleanest person to the point of OCD, and her food was always gourmet. but she just could not see well, or smell well at this age, and taking care of a house and another person was too much. She just needed a bit of help in these area. And cooking a Thanksgiving dinner!! Please. After you reach even 70, who needs it!
I am sure your mother is probably sick of doing this every year. Maybe next year, to keep everyone on neutral territory, you should take her out for dinner instead of making her cook it. Cooking dinner for a lot of people is HARD. Your brotyher is clueless. I think he thinks he means well... but he is on the wrong track.
I think what you are doing for your mother is lovely and don't let him tell you differently. You are a good daughter!! ~Jane
|
| Loading... | | |
| NGA |
|
| |
Reply with quote | #10 | APPLAUSE, APPLAUSE, for your well written, thoughtful, neutral email stating the facts. Good for you.
|
| Loading... | | |
| Lizzie42 |
|
| |
Reply with quote | #11 | What an absolutely *great* response! I think asking for his help in convincing mom to let you do a few small things was genius! Surely his ego will rise to the occasion. After all, that still leaves him in charge, right?!? (And you doing the work <sigh>
Just as an aside ... I too have a know-it-all big brother who thinks his way is the only way and always has. The thing I have often found difficult is that sometimes I'm sort of ... looking for his approval ... without even knowing I am. Realistically, I know it's highly unlikely I'll ever get that approval, so I've managed to quit looking (mostly), but every now and then I get caught in the old routines of "ok? ok? Ok? OK??" And of course, by his lights, it never is 'OK'.
You've done a great job of stating your case and now you must stand your ground. Even if he calls your mom and upsets her, make it your job to soothe your mom into letting you do what you know what needs doing, not catering to Mr. IKNOWEVERYTHINGABOUTEVERYBODYBETTERTHANTZHEYKNOWTH EMSELVES. My best guess is that mommy's golden boy can't or won't see the reality of the situation because he can't deal with change and the inevitability of old age and death, because then whose golden boy will he be?? But that's his problem, not yours and not mom's.
So get out in that kitchen and rattle those pots and pans!! (Boogie woogie) You're doing the right thing!
|
| Loading... | | |
| billie jo |
|
| |
Reply with quote | #12 | pq, that was a beautifully written letter. did you ever think of working for the gobbermint with the mid east peace talks? that was very well stated, non confrontational, expressing your mom's limitations without making her sound like a useless invalid and pointing out her normal daily rigorous work load. i think it was also wise to point out his influence over her, this can allow him to still be 'the man.' there was nothing in it that could have or should have been said differently. good luck on the response from him. keep in mind that he is who and what he is, so no matter what his response, you know you are doing the right thing. if mom protests after this, just point out to her that christmas is a family holiday, that you aren't a little kid waiting for santa, you want to be involved in the festivities and preparations too. let her know that you would enjoy being able to be part of helping with the christmas meal and using some of the cooking skills you learned from her. let her know you don't get many chances to participate in helping with a holiday meal and it would really be special for you. you want to be part of the tradition, not just an observer. so ask what part you could do and tell you you will do your best to see that it is as good as hers. good luck. hang in there, you are in the right. you may also tell her that you read all the holiday cooking magazines and would love to try to make something from them, goodie wise, but need some guinea pigs to serve them too. see how she responds to that. deserts are a lot easier to transport long distance that main course dishes, and they can usually be frozen ahead of time. also ask if you can set the christmas table, it will give you the opportunity to place name cards with your brother's on a tv tray in the living room!!! lol let us know how it is going. again. brother would have to read some really tiny print to find anything objectionable to your email. you are a sweet daughter. if he is awful, let it roll off. it only means he is an insensitive person who will never get a clue.
|
| Loading... | | |
| billie jo |
|
| |
Reply with quote | #13 |
sorry, didn't mean to ramble and preach. these are just things we had to do with my mom, the queen bee, to get her to let us share in the work. she was also one who would work herself to the bone even though she had 5 daughters willing to help out. it was her hive!! eventually dinners turned into pot lucks with everyone stating what they were bringing and mom coordinating it. we all were allowed to flex or martha stewart muscles and had wonderful dinners enjoyed by all. cleanup was also a joint effort and was done in the blink of an eye. mom directed where everything was to be put away. [interesting little sidenote, well not really, but i will add it.] there were 5 girls and our baby brother. all the sis's were on board and brought their best efforts. the quiet family joke was our only sil was probably going to bring the green bean casserole, and it NEVER failed. canned green beans, mushroom soup and crunchy onions! and always went outside for a cigarette while the clean up went on!!!! merry christmas. |
| Loading... | | |
| Lynn from Oz | |
| Janice |
|
| |
Reply with quote | #15 |
Oh my Billie Jo! LOLOL My husband has a sister in law that brings her awful green bean casserole every time too! AND she sits all cuddled up to her husband and watches football while the rest of us clean up! Funny thing is though that the joke is on her because we talk and laugh and actually have a good time while she sits in there in her boredom. PQ I didn't mean to steal your thread!
|
| Loading... | | |